Pros and Cons of No CM Punk in WWE

The last time we saw CM Punk, Corporate Kane was eliminating him from the Royal Rumble and chokeslamming him through the Spanish announce table. Looked brutal enough, but I’m sure I’m not the only one who thought he’d brush it off and show up the next night on Raw seeking vengeance. Of course, that never happened.

wwe-royal-rumble-2011-2012-cm-punk

We haven’t seen him, but we’ve heard plenty about CM Punk since the Royal Rumble, most of it speculation regarding his WWE status. Nothing is official at this point, but sources from sports journalist Dave Meltzer to your cousin’s dirt sheet have reported that there are problems between the WWE and CM Punk, whose contract is reportedly set to expire this coming July. Some say he was released. Others say he essentially took his ball and quietly walked home.

The story is all over the place but the one constant is that CM Punk hasn’t been on WWE TV in some time. It got me to to thinking:  if he truly is gone, it could be a gamechanging situation with both good and bad implications behind it.

Since the explosive pipe bomb of 2011, CM Punk has consistently been one of the top three guys on the active WWE roster. After delivering the memorable promo that blurred the lines between kayfabe and reality, he went on a lengthy run fueled by a push of epic proportions. That roll, of course, saw him hold the WWE Championship for an astounding 434 days. At the height of his run, you could even say that he was the number two guy behind Cena, and it terms of fan reaction, easily the most popular superstar on the roster.

So what could possibly be behind the disappearance of CM Punk, who’s still incredibly over amid the Yes Movement? The rumor mill claims that he is not happy with his current status on the roster. He’s pretty much been out of the title picture since dropping the WWE Championship to the Rock last year and slowly drifted further from serious contention since. After the Rumble, I thought we might get a brief CM Punk vs. Kane feud leading into a match against Triple H at Wrestlemania 30 – pretty much the same angle Daniel Bryan looks to be involved in now. Whatever storyline WWE creative penned for CM Punk seemed to be the straw that caused the five-time world champion to take a step back – or could there be more?

There’s a letter making its rounds on the interwebs that shines a jaded light on the whole CM Punk story. This letter, purportedly written by an anonymous WWE employee, paints the picture of a giant egomaniac who can’t handle not being in the spotlight. The employee claimed that Punk was jealous of Daniel Bryan and became tougher to deal with backstage as Bryan’s popularity continued to soar. You have to take what an anonymous source spews with the tiniest grain of salt, but this report was chatter worthy fodder for IWC detractors who believe Punk is a self-absorbed jerk in it for himself.

When a top star goes down, there is a trickle down effect that warrants everyone else to step their game up. The booking team is forced to exercise their creativity on the fly and quickly come up with new ideas, while talent has to be ready to perform at another level when their number is called. No CM Punk would leave a huge gap, but it gives other wrestlers a chance to step up and seize an opportunity they may have not been afforded otherwise. It could be the reason why guys like Cesaro get a title shot, and the motivation behind NXT guys like Sami Zayn finally being called up to the main roster.

Now I’m not the biggest CM Punk mark, but I can certainly see some downsides to him being gone. He has been in some big time angles since the infamous pipe bomb promo. Before the whole Heyman stable rivalry, he was always in the top one or two programs, putting on quality matches with the likes of Alberto Del Rio, heel Daniel Bryan, and even Ryback of all people – the “FEED ME MORE!” Ryback who was actually building a following before creative pulled the plug and effectively killed his push. There were also programs with the Rock, Undertaker and Lesnar, which resulted in losses, yet produced quality matches while giving Punk credibility at the same time.

CM Punk has been a major focal point of WWE programming for nearly three years straight. At times, he’s been one of few draws that made Raw tolerable. His promos were the only talking segments you actually looked forward to. If you’re a Phil Brooks mark or just think the product is flat out stale at the moment, life with no CM Punk may take some getting used to. It could easily be the Miz sliding into a title match and Bo Dallas coming to the roster as the lost Wyatt. I’m saying it could get uglier before it gets better.

And Show Goes On

It’s possible that CM Punk will make his triumph return just in time for Wrestlemania 30. Or maybe he’ll resurface in a few months and treat us to yet another “Summer of Punk”. He could be done with wrestling for good. It’s all up in the air, but the one thing we do know is that the WWE train will keep rolling. Stone Cold Steven Austin, Bret Hart, and even Hulk Hogan all reminded us that no one man is bigger than the company. CM Punk may regret whatever decision he makes, and the fans may suffer through it. The WWE will thrive with or without the self-proclaimed Best in the World.

wwe-cm-punk-jr2012

Tags

  • Kalib James

    I personally think he’ll be back soon. Just can’t see him walking away during Wrestlemania season. Definitely can’t see that going over well with Vince, so if he did come back sometime later it might work against him. Wouldn’t be surprised if he got the Dolph Ziggler treatment for a minute. But if he is gone for any extended period of time I have to say it’s a good thing. Gives other guys an opportunity for exposure and pushes they might not have gotten. Call me crazy, but I think Daniel Bryan benefited from Sheamus being out last year. Would he really got a Summer Slam match with Cena and the feud with Orton/Authority if HHH’s buddy Sheamus was around? Guess we’ll know Punk’s long-term status soon enough.

  • James Jones

    Apart from the annoying chants I haven’t even missed Punk. He’s good and all but I just don’t see him not being around as some big loss. I think losing a guy like Cena, Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton even would hurt a lot more. He’ll probably be back sooner or later unless he’s just done for good. Can’t see him going back to ROH. Definitely not TNA. Its WWE or nothing. But if he does go out like this just quitting because he can’t get his way I see that doing some damage to his legacy.

  • Silent Bob

    I think Punk left when he was in a bad storyline, which has made things easier. If he had left halfway through something that people actually cared about, I think people would be wanting him back more.
    i personnally hope he does come back, AND gets a push for the title again. Daniel Bryan is a great wrestler, but is no way “face of the company” for me – there is nobody there to make a believable champion, which is why we get stuck with the same old thing.

    We all know that they will bring money in the bank back for wrestlemania (as there is only 1 MITB match again now), and we we all know DB will win, cash in on whoever wins the boring title match, and win. Then we have a tramp as the champ – awesome…..

Latest Articles

WWE RAW Results: August 21, 2017

WWE RAW Results: August 21, 2017

Review: LOGAN LUCKY is redneck heist “done good”

Review: LOGAN LUCKY is redneck heist “done good”

WWE SummerSlam 2017 Results

WWE SummerSlam 2017 Results

NXT TakeOver Brooklyn III Results

NXT TakeOver Brooklyn III Results

Your SO OF COURSE preview of WWE SummerSlam 2017, brought to you by Game of Thrones!

Your SO OF COURSE preview of WWE SummerSlam 2017, brought to you by Game of Thrones!

WWE Spoilers: Final card for NXT TakeOver Brooklyn III

WWE Spoilers: Final card for NXT TakeOver Brooklyn III

REMEMBER NXT? Preview of NXT TAKEOVER BROOKLYN III

REMEMBER NXT? Preview of NXT TAKEOVER BROOKLYN III

WWE Spoilers: Final card for SummerSlam 2017

WWE Spoilers: Final card for SummerSlam 2017

WWE SmackDown LIVE Results: August 15, 2017

WWE SmackDown LIVE Results: August 15, 2017

WWE RAW Results: August 14, 2017

WWE RAW Results: August 14, 2017

Twin Peaks 2017 Review: Part 14 – Okay, so last week was gently numbing us to prepare for this week!

Twin Peaks 2017 Review: Part 14 – Okay, so last week was gently numbing us to prepare for this week!

Interview: Jay Lethal

Interview: Jay Lethal

Review: ANABELLE CREATION proves the Conjuring universe still has life

Review: ANABELLE CREATION proves the Conjuring universe still has life